Updated: 5 days ago
Growing up on Long Island, Manhattan and its legendary theatres would call
out to me in my sleepy town of Massapequa. Don’t get me wrong, there was
plenty of local culture: Billy Joel, Steve Guttenberg, the Mets. These are our
local heroes and pop culture touchstones. But just an hour ride westbound on
the Long Island Rail Road there exists another kind of show. Once a month
on Wednesdays, my mother and I would get into the city in time to get to the
TKTS booth and see a Broadway matinee. We bonded over some great shows
and some not-so-great ones.
We’d take turns each week picking which play we’d see, from the tortured ninety minutes of a tight drama, to the spectacle featuring three-hours of show tunes. There was always magic in those afternoons. The trick to pulling off a memorable film adaptation from a piece written for the stage is adding just the right amount of technical artistry.
Cinematography, editing, and scoring can achieve so much, but not losing the
immediacy of a story going down in the room you’re sitting in is what makes it
work. The balance has to be just right. And when that happens, it can blow your
New York State of Mind. To me, these are the movies that have made the most
out of their transformations from stage to screen:
#1 Passing Strange
Tomato Meter 100% - Audience 89%
Critic Consensus: Spike Lee's document of the Tony Award-winning musical Passing Strange is every bit as compelling onscreen as it was on stage.
Of course, there has to be at least one musical represented here, and this is a killer. Shot during the last performance of its 2008 Broadway run, Passing Strange is a
personal story that ends up in the telling to be undeniably universal. Although live theatre shot directly for film is becoming more popular, this is included here
because it makes you feel like you’re practically on stage. The man of the hour is Stew, a singer-songwriter and first-time playwright, who strikes a joyous tone with this coming-of-middle-age saga.
Blessed with an outsized stage presence and material to match (the play won the Tony Award for Best Book), Stew narrates his time growing up in Los Angeles, moving to Amsterdam, and finding his own truth. The actors and band members are having a blast from the opening moments to the roof-raising encore. Spike Lee directs with just the right touch, capturing the show’s particularly fluid sense of time and place. He turns what
could have been a simple presentation into a rollicking testament, by deftly
establishing a feel for the good vibes rippling through the very live audience that
#2 Who's Afraid of Virginia Wolf
Tomatometer 95 - Audience Score 91
Critic Consensus: Led by a volcanic performance from Elizabeth Taylor, Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf? is a scathing adaptation of the Edward Albee play that serves as a brilliant calling card for debuting director Mike Nichols.
This may be the best, most ferocious example of how galvanizing a play
turned into a film can be. Edward Albee’s scorching high drama follows the
interactions between two couples over a single evening. George and Martha,
who lay out emotional and mental minefields for each other (and their
unsuspecting guests), have been satirized and parodied for over half a century.
There’s not a barb or insult lost when the psychic warfare is captured for the
screen. Ernest Lehman wrote the screenplay, and he stays true to the ferocity
of Albee’s language. Mike Nichols, using his experience from years of creating
great theatre, makes a powerful directorial debut. The movie has the feel of a
boxing match thanks to the stunning craft of cinematographer Haskell Wexler.
The main attraction is the dazzling depictions of George and Martha from real-life married couple Richard Burton and Elizabeth Taylor. This movie does what
seems impossible, taking the most intimate of dramas and committing it to film
without allowing any of the dread to escape. Taylor gained about twenty-five
pounds for the role, and went on to win the Academy Award for best actress,
one of thirteen Oscars for which the film was nominated. The least we can do is
watch her devour this material in a career-defining portrayal. This is a towering
achievement and a must-see.
#3 Wait Until Dark
Tomatometer 96 - Audience Score 91
Critic Consensus: Nail-bitingly tense and brilliantly acted, Wait Until Dark is a compact thriller that makes the most of its fiendishly clever premise.
In Frederick Knott’s play, a game of cat and mouse works the audience’s nerves
right up until the shriek-inducing climax. In the 1967 film, Audrey Hepburn plays
Susy, a blind woman who is slowly terrorized in her New York apartment.
Terence Young, who directed three of the first four James Bond films, summons
all his movie-making magic towards teasing out every ounce of suspense. The
screenplay, by Robert and Jane-Howard Carrington, keeps every scene as tight
as a rush-hour subway car. Academy Award winners are all over this movie, with